Here’s my review for EI. The found the book to be something of a let down:
At the root of such problems is Harms’ fundamental approach, which he spells out in the preface: “I have sought to present the history of the conflict in a balanced and actual light” (xv). The aim of imposing the prism of “balance” on the fundamentally imbalanced situation of a settler movement’s ongoing colonization of an occupied land is doomed to failure. This lies at the heart of much of what is wrong with the book.
I travelled to Israel in June and realized what evil has been done by archeologists and how tourism has become the greed that sealed the error into tradition. Fell free to contact me.please.